Gas vs. Wood Fire Pits: Which is Right for You?

Featured Images: Linear Gas Fire Pit in Carbon Steel by Fire Pit Art and DIY Round Wood Burning Fire Pit Kit by Travertine & More

 

Whether you're gathering friends for a summer barbecue or cozying up with family on a chilly evening, a fire pit can transform your outdoor space into a year-round haven. But when it comes to choosing the right fire pit, the decision between gas vs. wood fire pit options can be a puzzle. Each type offers distinct advantages and brings its own unique ambiance to your backyard. 

In this guide, we'll dive deep into the pros and cons of gas vs. wood fire pits, and cover topics such as ease of use, maintenance, cost, and environmental impact. By the end, you'll have all the information you need to decide which fire pit is the best fit for your outdoor entertaining needs and lifestyle preferences.

What's better, a wood or gas fire pit?

The better option depends on your preferences for convenience, maintenance, environmental impact, and ambiance. Gas fire pits offer ease of use and cleanliness, while wood fire pits provide a traditional experience and natural ambiance.

Let’s take a closer look at gas vs. wood fire pit pros and cons.

Gas vs wood fire pits pros and cons

The Fire Surfer Gas Fire Pit and Fire Surfer Wood Burning Fire Pit by Fire Pit Art

What are the pros of a gas fire pit?

• Convenience and Control: Gas fire pits usually offer easy ignition and control over the flame, making them convenient to use. You can start and stop the fire with a simple switch or knob.
• Cleanliness: Unlike wood fire pits, gas pits don’t produce ash or smoke. This means less cleanup and no smoke smell on clothing or hair.
• Safety: Gas fire pits produce a steady flame without the sparks and embers that come from wood fires, reducing the risk of accidental fires.
• Versatility and Design: Gas fire pits can be installed in a variety of designs and materials to match any outdoor decor. They can also be built into permanent structures like tables or benches.
• Environmental Impact: Generally, gas fire pits are considered more environmentally friendly compared to wood, as they burn cleaner and produce fewer emissions.

What are the cons of a gas fire pit?

• Initial Cost and Installation: Gas fire pits typically have higher initial costs due to the need for professional installation, especially if a natural gas line is required. This can significantly increase the overall expense.
• Lack of Authenticity: Gas fire pits don't offer the same natural ambiance as wood fire pits. They lack the sound of crackling wood and the characteristic smell of a wood fire, which many find appealing.
• Dependence on Fuel Supply: Gas fire pits require a continuous supply of propane or natural gas. If you use propane, you'll need to regularly check and refill or replace propane tanks.
• Limited Heat Output: While gas fire pits provide consistent flame and warmth, they generally do not emit as much heat as wood fire pits, which might be a drawback in colder settings.
• Complexity in Repair: Compared to wood fire pits, gas fire pits have more components that can malfunction, such as burners, valves, and ignitions systems. Repairs may require professional service, adding to maintenance costs.
• Utility Costs: If connected to a natural gas line, the cost of running a gas fire pit will add to your monthly utility bills, unlike wood, which may be free or less expensive depending on your source.
• Regulatory Restrictions: In some areas, the installation and use of gas fire pits are heavily regulated. You might need permits or have to comply with specific safety regulations, which can complicate installation.

What are the pros of a wood burning fire pit?

• Ambiance: Wood fire pits offer a traditional campfire experience with the natural sounds of crackling wood and the familiar smell of smoke to enhance your outdoor ambiance.
• Heat Output: Wood fires generally provide more radiant heat than gas fires, making them ideal for colder climates.
• Cost of Fuel: Depending on your location, wood can be a cheaper option for fuel compared to propane or natural gas.
• No Need for Fuel Lines: Wood fire pits do not require access to natural gas lines or propane tanks, making them more adaptable to different locations.
• Cooking Capability: Wood fire pits are excellent for grilling or cooking traditional campfire foods, adding a functional benefit to their use.

What are the cons of a wood burning fire pit?

• Maintenance and Cleanup: Wood fire pits require more maintenance than gas fire pits. You need to regularly clean out ash and occasionally remove soot buildup.
• Smoke and Odor: Burning wood produces smoke, which can be irritating to the eyes and respiratory system, and leaves a lingering smell on clothes and hair.
• Fire Risks: Wood fire pits produce sparks and embers that can pose a fire hazard, especially in dry conditions or near flammable materials.
• Fuel Storage: You need space to store wood, which must be kept dry and protected from the elements.
• Environmental Concerns: Wood fire pits emit particulate matter and other pollutants, which can have a negative impact on air quality.

What kind of fire pit is best for the environment?

Gas fire pits are generally considered more environmentally friendly as they produce fewer emissions and do not contribute to deforestation. Wood fire pits emit smoke and particulates into the air.

Top Outdoor Gas vs Wood Fire Pits

1. "Bella Luna" Gas Burning Fire Pit

Ideal for: Traditionalists who love classic designs

Features: This fire pit has an elegant, moon-inspired half-dome design with a steel ring and robust construction. Its soothing aesthetics can complement any garden or patio decor. It is available as both a gas and wood fire pit.

2. ”Linear Gas” Fire Pit

Ideal for: Homeowners who entertain frequently and prefer a functional piece that doubles as a stylish furniture element.

Features: This pit exhibits clean lines and a long rectangular fire bowl that provides an unobstructed view of the flames no matter the seating arrangement. It comes with a steel cover to easily convert the pit into a table for added functionality, along with steel leveling casters.

3. "Magnum" Gas Burning Fire Pit in Steel

Ideal for: Large groups and entertainment.

Features: With its larger size, the 270 pound Magnum Fire Pit is ideal for entertaining larger crowds, offering ample space for firewood, and greater heat distribution. It's perfect for hosting big gatherings and ensuring everyone stays warm. Order it as either a gas or wood fire pit. A smaller, 135 pound version, known as the Saturn Fire Pit is also available.

4. Vesuvius Wood Burning Wood Fire Pit

Ideal for: Enthusiasts looking for a non-traditional fire pit shape and style. Perfect for those seeking a unique outdoor addition with a transitional aesthetic.

Features: This pit is individually made by hand and is signed/numbered by the artisan. It is made of high-strength carbon steel and stands nearly 4-feet tall.

5. Square Wood Burning Smokeless Fire Pit DIY Kit 

Ideal for: Homeowners and DIY enthusiasts looking for a stylish fire pit that complements modern outdoor spaces and minimizes smoke output.

Features: This kit comes complete with a durable 11-gauge steel smokeless insert and precision-cut tumbled stones, ensuring a seamless setup for a stunning, smoke-free fire experience.

Gas vs. Wood Fire Pits FAQ

How much does a gas vs wood fire pit cost?

• Installation costs for gas fire pits can be higher due to the need for a gas line, which may require professional installation. Wood fire pits can often be set up at a lower cost and with less infrastructure needed. The prices can vary widely by model from $150 to $8,000.

What maintenance is required for wood vs gas fire pits?

• Wood fire pits require regular cleaning to remove ash and debris, and occasional checks to ensure safety from fire hazards. Gas fire pits need less frequent maintenance but should have periodic inspections of gas lines and connections to ensure there are no leaks.

Can I cook over a gas fire pit like I can with a wood fire pit?

• Yes, but it depends on the design of the gas fire pit. Some gas fire pits are designed for aesthetic appeal rather than functional cooking, unlike wood fire pits, which are naturally suited for grilling.

Are gas fire pits safer than wood fire pits?

• Generally, yes, because they don’t produce sparks or embers that can cause accidental fires. However, long term safety also depends on proper installation and maintenance.

Gas and Wood Fire Pits for Sale at Fountainful!

Start creating cherished memories today with Fountaintful's Fire Pit Collection. We'd be honored to assist with your selection. Explore our entire collection of exceptional fire pits online at Fountainful.com. 

Questions about our products? Contact us today at 214-901-7275!